You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Given $$X = \mathbb{R}^L$$, for every two bundles $$x, y \in X$$, $$x \succeq y$$ if and only if $$x_k \ge y_k \forall k$$.
a) Preferences are complete if for every two bundles $$x, y \in X$$, either $$x \succeq y$$ or $$x \preceq y$$ or $$x \sim y$$. Consider two bundles $$x,y$$, with $$x_i > y_i$$ and $$x_j < y_j$$. Then $$x \npreceq y$$ and $$x \nsucceq y$$, so they preferences are not complete.
b) Preferences are transitive if for any bundles $$x,y,z \in X$$, if $$x \succeq y$$ and $$y \succeq z$$, then $$x \succeq z$$.
Assume that $$x \succeq y$$ and $$y \succeq z$$. Then by the preference relation above, $$x_k \ge y_k \forall k$$ and $$y_k \ge z_k \forall k$$. Substituting, we can see that $$x_k \ge y_k \ge z_k \Rightarrow x_k \ge z_k \forall k$$, hence $$x \succeq z$$.
c) Preferences are strongly monotonic if $$x_k \ge y_k \forall k$$ and $$x \neq y$$ implies $$x \succ y$$. But by the above preference, $$x_k \ge y_k \forall k$$ implies only that $$x \succeq y$$, so the preferences are not strongly monotonic.
d) Preferences are strictly convex if for any three bundles $$x, y, z \in X$$, with $$x \preceq z$$, $$y \preceq z$$, and $$x \neq z$$, $$ax + (1-a)y \prec z \forall a \in (0,1)$$.
Since $$x \preceq z$$, $$y \preceq z$$, we know that $$x_k \ge z_k$$ and $$y_k \ge z_k \forall k$$. In addition, $$x \neq z \Rightarrow x_i > z_i$$ for some $$i$$. Also, since $$a \in (0,1)$$, $$ax_k + (1-a)y_k \ge z_k \forall k$$ and $$ax_i + (1-a)y_i > z_i$$ for at least one $$i$$. This implies that $$ax + (1-a)y \ge z$$, and $$ax + (1-a)y \neq z$$, so $$ax + (1-a)y \succeq z but the reverse is not true. Therefore, $$ax + (1-a)y \succ z$$.
2. Checking properties of a preference relation
Consider a consumer with $$x = (x_1, x_2) \succeq y = (y_1, y_2)$$ if and only if $$\max{x_1, x_2} \ge \min{y_1, y_2}$$.
a) The consumer weakly prefers $$x$$ to $$y$$ if the maximum component of $$x$$ is at least as valuable as the minimum component of $$y$$. That is, if a single component of $$x$$ is larger than the smallest component of $$y$$, the consumer prefers $$x$$ to $$y$$, or is indifferent between $$x$$ and $$y$$.
b) The preferences have the following properties:
Completeness: The preferences are complete, since $$x \succeq y \Rightarrow \max(x) \ge \min(y)$$, and $$x \preceq y \Rightarrow \max(x) \le \min(y)$$, so any two bundles $$x,y \in X$$ are comparable.
Transitive: Preferences are not transitive, as an example will show. Let $$x = (1,5)$$, $$y = (2,8)$$, and $$z = (6,7)$$. Then $$x \succeq y$$ since $$\max{x_i} \ge \min{y_i}$$ and $$y \succeq z$$ since $$\max{y_i} \ge \min{z_i}$$, but $$\max{x_i} \le \min{z_i}$$, so $$x \preceq z$$.
Monotone: By the definition of monotone, $$x_k \ge y_k \forall k \Rightarrow x \succeq y$$ and $$x_k > y_k \forall k \Rightarrow x \succ y$$. Assume $$x_k \ge y_k \forall k$$. Then $$\max(x) \ge \min(y)$$, so $$x \succeq y$$. Now assume $$x_k > y_k \forall k$$. Then $$\max(x) > \min(y)$$, but $$\max(y)$$ can be greater or equal to $$min(x)$$, so the second requirement of monotinicity does not hold. Hence the preferences are not monotonic. An example is illustrative. Let $$x = (2,10)$$ and $$y = (1,9)$$. Then $$x_k > y_k \forall k$$ and $$max(x) > min(y)$$ so $$x \succeq y$$. But $$max(y) > min(x)$$, so $$y \succeq x$$. Since $$x \succeq y$$ and $$y \succeq x$$, it does not hold that $$x_k > y_k \Rightarrow x \sim y$$, so the preferences are not monotonic.
XXX * Convex: Let $$x \succeq z$$ and $$y \succeq z$$, with $$x \neq z$$ and $$y \neq z$$. If the preferences are convex, then $$\alpha x + (1 - \alpha)y \succeq z \Rightarrow \max(\alpha x + (1-\alpha)y) \ge \min(z)$$. Since We can rewrite this as $$\max(\alpha x + (1-\alpha)y) \ge \min(z) Then $$\max(\alpha x + (1-\alpha) y) \ge \min(z)$$. $$. Since $$x \succeq z \Rightarrow \max(x) \ge \min(z)$$ and $$y \succeq z \Rightarrow \max(y) \ge \min(z)$$, and with $$\alpha \in (0,1)$$, $$\alpha
Locally Non-Satiated: The preference relation is not LNS. A preference relation is LNS if for any scalar $$\epsilon > 0$$ you can define a new bundle $$y$ where $$||x - y|| < \epsilon$$, such that $$y \succ x$$. In this case, $$y \succ x \Rightarrow \max(y) \ge \min(x)$$ and $$\max(x) < \min(y)$$. Choose $$y = x + \frac{\epsilon}{2}$$ for some $$\epsilon$$. Then
Consider preferences defined on $$X \in \mathbb{R}^2_{+}$$.
XXX a) Preferences are convex if the convex combination of bundles is preferred over a single bundle alone, or given $$x = (x_1,x_2)$$ and $$y = (y_1,y_2)$$, $$x \succeq y \Rightarrow ax + (1-a)y \succeq y$$. Solving, we get
$$\begin{align}
\frac{ax}{y} + 1 - a &\ge 1 \\
\frac{ax}{y} &\ge a \\
\frac{x}{y} &\ge 1 \\
x &\ge y
\end{align}
$$
Since $$x \ge y$$, the preferences are convex.
b) Given $$U(x) = x_1 x_2$$,
4. Quasi-Linear Preferences
XXX
5. Rubinstein PS 2
3). Given $$\succeq$$ be continuous preferences on $$X \subseteq \mathbb{R}^n$$ that contains the interval connecting points $$x$$ and $$z$$. Show that if $$y \in X$$ and $$x \succeq y \succeq z$$, then there exists a point $$m$$ on that interval such that $$y \sim m$$.
Following the Bolzano-Weierstrass theorem, let $$I \subseteq X$$ be the interval connecting $$x$$ and $$z$$, and $$y \in X$$ a third point with $$x \succeq y \succeq z$$. Inductively, define two sequences of points in $$I$$, $${x_t}$$ and $${z_t}$$. Construct $$x_t$$ and $$z_t$$ in the following way. Define $$x_0 = x$$ and $$z_0 = z$$. Since $$x \succeq z$$ and $$x_t \in I$$, $$x \succeq x_t \forall t$$. Similarly, $$z \preceq z_t \forall t$$. Now choose a point $$m$$ such that $$x_t \succeq m \succeq z_t$$. Then since $$x \succeq y \succeq z$$, either $$m \succeq y$$ or $$y \succeq m$$ or both. In the first case, define $$x_{t+1} = m$$ and $$z_{t+1} = z_t$$. In the second, define $$z_{t+1} = m$$ and $$x_{t+1} = x_t$$. The sequences $${x_t}$$ and $${z_t}$$ are conversing, and they converge to $$y$$ because $$\lim_{t \to \infty} |x_t - z_t| = 0$$. Since the preferences are continuous, at that point we have $$m \succeq y$$ and $$y \succeq m$$, so $$m \sim y$$.
XXX 4). Consider $$(\succeq^n){n=1,2,...}$$, defined on $$\mathbb{R}^2{+}$$, where $$\succeq^n$$ is represented by $$u_n(x_1, x_2) = x^n_1 + x^n_2$$. Say that the sequence $$\succeq^n$$ converges to preferences
5).
6). Given $$X \in \mathbb{R}^2_{+}$$, assume that $$\succeq$$ satisfies additivity, strong monotonicity, and continuity. Define $$x = (x_1, x_2)$$ and $$y = (y_1, y_2)$$, where $$x,y \in X$$.
a) Given $$\succeq$$ is linear, that is, $$u(x) = \alpha x_1 + \beta x_2, \alpha, \beta > 0$$, show that it has the following properties:
Additivity: Let $$u(x) \succeq u(y)$$. Then $$\alpha x_1 + \beta x_2 \ge